To me it is almost beyond belief that the FBI lost the cigarette butts. There should be a clear written record of where they were stored and who had access to them. FBI agents are especially well trained on evidence handling and the importance of preserving chain of custody records.
You do not just go into an evidence locker and take out what you need. You have to log in, identify what you are examining or removing and if something is not returned there will be a clear written record showing who last possessed it.
Lost is not acceptable. Lost by who? When? Where?
377
All good questions, 377.
Related is how the FBI actually functions, in particular in its crime labs. Rermember, in the late 1990s the DOJ investigated the FBI's primary crime lab operation in DC upon the ten-year's worth of whistleblowing alarms set off by one of their surpervisory agents, Dr. Frederick Whitehurst.
In that investigation they found the following:
1. FBI lab techs manufactured fake evidence.
2. FBI lab techs lied in court about their findings.
3. FBI lab techs routinely lost evidence, and / or their documentation was lost, incomplete, misleading, or inaccurate.
4. Some FBI lab techs were not qualified to work in their particular unit. Many were not even scientifically trained. In fact, some were just special agents shifted to the lab from field assignments.
5. The overarching goal - the culture in the lab - was to get a conviction. Truth, or solid evidence, was secondary.
6. Over four-dozen recommendations were delivered to the Attorney General to clean up the mess in the FBI lab. It's unclear how many were enacted. However, no one faced criminal charges. Nevertheless, Whitehurst was forced out of the Bureau.
7. FBI Profiler John Douglas has publicly declared that the FBI has an inside joke: "We can convict anyone. It's just that the innocent take longer."
The cigarette butts were lost shortly after the Attorney General released his report on the investigation. An NPR documentary was produced detailing these proceedings.