Author Topic: Flight Path And Related Issues  (Read 1102446 times)

Offline Bill Rollins

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 39
  • Thanked: 1 times
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1110 on: October 24, 2016, 08:59:30 PM »
I say Cooper was an intelligent man who carefully planned this hijacking.

Rather than get caught in a roadblock trying to drive away from the dropzone, Cooper had a boat waiting in the Lewis River just downstream of the Merwin Dam.  He took this boat down the Lewis River, up the Columbia to Tena Bar, where his pickup truck and boat trailer were waiting.  During the period of transferring money from his boat to the truck, he loses a few bundles.  These bundles are what was found by Brian Ingram over 8 years later.

So the money got to Tena Bar on the night of the hijacking.  Three of the discovered bundles were intact, but deteriorated.  A fourth bundle probably was nearer the surface and its elastic band broke.  This bundle of money decayed and the fragments got spread around in the vicinity.  Some of these bill fragments may have been washed or blown away.  I think Galen Cook mentions some young fisherman, prior to Brian Ingram's find, saw some individual bill sections on the beach up to 100 yards away. 

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
 

Offline Shutter

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 9300
  • Thanked: 1025 times
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1111 on: October 24, 2016, 09:18:12 PM »
If they are correct about the sand layers, how do you explain the dredge layer below the money found in 1980? your theory is based on Cooper jumping at the original time, and landing near Lake Merwin.
 

Offline Bruce A. Smith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4365
  • Thanked: 465 times
    • The Mountain News
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1112 on: October 24, 2016, 09:31:17 PM »
Yo, Bill, the money shards were found buried three feet below Brian's bundles. That's the rub. How does one account for two very different money finds? (!)
 

Offline Bill Rollins

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 39
  • Thanked: 1 times
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1113 on: October 24, 2016, 09:40:17 PM »
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
If they are correct about the sand layers, how do you explain the dredge layer below the money found in 1980? your theory is based on Cooper jumping at the original time, and landing near Lake Merwin.

Tom Kaye has said that they got it wrong concerning the dredge layers at the money find.  The dredge layers were south of the actual money location.

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login

Under Research conclusions, the Sleuths write; "The money find on Tena Bar is complicated. The rubber band experiments allow less than a year for the money to become entombed in the sand. The money continues to resist all natural explanations for how it arrived on Tena Bar. The story behind the money may be as big as the Cooper story itself. There is no hard evidence that Cooper died in the jump so it remains a primary debate. If Cooper walked out of the woods, there would certainly be easier ways to explain the money if human intervention was involved."

So there you have their analysis: Less than one year for the money to become entombed in the sand.

At the D. B. Cooper Symposium in 2011, Tom Kaye states: "...there is no way the $5,800 in Cooper's cash found years after the hijacking by 8-year-old Brian Ingram in a sand bar on the Columbia River northwest of Vancouver could have gotten there naturally".

This all seems to support a theory where Cooper inadvertently loses the money as he escapes on the evening of the hijacking.
 

Offline Bill Rollins

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 39
  • Thanked: 1 times
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1114 on: October 24, 2016, 09:51:39 PM »
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Yo, Bill, the money shards were found buried three feet below Brian's bundles. That's the rub. How does one account for two very different money finds? (!)

Bruce, I can only conjecture, but it is my belief that there was a fourth bundle (up to 35 more serial numbers have been identified by piecing some of the money fragments together).  The rubber bands on this bundle broke, and the fragments as well as the center of the bills began to decay.  These fragments were free to move individually, as they were no longer retained as a bundle.  With the wind and the water current, some of these fragments may have moved, and then got buried by sediment in the river water (I'm not sure where the seasonal high water mark might be relative to the location of the 3 bundles). 

In any event, I say that the fourth bundle was decayed and its fragments were distributed naturally by the action of the wind and water currents.
« Last Edit: October 24, 2016, 09:53:54 PM by Bill Rollins »
 

Offline Shutter

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 9300
  • Thanked: 1025 times
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1115 on: October 24, 2016, 09:52:14 PM »
He seems to base this on the Fazio's only pushing the sand 50 yards in each direction...almost 200,000 cubic yards were placed on the shoreline. I find it hard to believe they only utilized a small portion of the constant eroding shoreline. no records state the sand was moved off the beach. so, they would basically, leave most of the dredge pile untouched....

Tom also states

Quote
we can speculate that he must have had some human interaction that could have eventually led to the money being buried on Tena Bar. How the Cooper bundles came to be buried where they were remains as big a mystery as who D.B. Cooper was.
« Last Edit: October 24, 2016, 10:18:37 PM by Shutter »
 

Offline Bill Rollins

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 39
  • Thanked: 1 times
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1116 on: October 24, 2016, 10:45:57 PM »
And, of course, human interaction can mean that Cooper transported the money on the night in question to Tena Bar as he made his getaway. 

The other significant detail related to Tena Bar is that Cooper leaves from here via a small boat (I say an inflatable like a Zodiac) at noon to reach PDX and then walks to the airport terminal (Zodiac tied up along shoreline of Columbia near PDX).  After the hijacking, and jumping out, he goes to his boat located downstream of Merwin Dam, and tools down the Lewis River and then up river to Tena Bar.  Once he has the money and his aluminum boat secured on the trailer, he drives through Vancouver and across the bridge to Portland.  He drives along NE Marine drive to the Zodiac, deflates it, and loads it into the aluminum boat.

So from this location (Tena Bar), not only does he get 20 miles away from the drop zone elusively and in a short period of time, he also returns to the shoreline near PDX to take away any evidence that he was ever at the airport.

With this in mind, there are no longer any "mysteries" regarding the night of November 24, 1971.  Cooper escaped with the money!
 

Robert99

  • Guest
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1117 on: October 25, 2016, 12:23:30 AM »
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
And, of course, human interaction can mean that Cooper transported the money on the night in question to Tena Bar as he made his getaway. 

The other significant detail related to Tena Bar is that Cooper leaves from here via a small boat (I say an inflatable like a Zodiac) at noon to reach PDX and then walks to the airport terminal (Zodiac tied up along shoreline of Columbia near PDX).  After the hijacking, and jumping out, he goes to his boat located downstream of Merwin Dam, and tools down the Lewis River and then up river to Tena Bar.  Once he has the money and his aluminum boat secured on the trailer, he drives through Vancouver and across the bridge to Portland.  He drives along NE Marine drive to the Zodiac, deflates it, and loads it into the aluminum boat.

So from this location (Tena Bar), not only does he get 20 miles away from the drop zone elusively and in a short period of time, he also returns to the shoreline near PDX to take away any evidence that he was ever at the airport.

With this in mind, there are no longer any "mysteries" regarding the night of November 24, 1971.  Cooper escaped with the money!

Bill,

First, let me say welcome to the thread and you certainly seem to be more stable emotionally than Bruce Smith was indicating recently.

Basically, in your statements above you are assuming that Cooper knew his location when he jumped.  Actually, the airliner was above a 5000 foot overcast and several lower cloud layers and it is very, very unlikely that he could estimate his positon to within a radius of 20 miles.  Your statements require pinpoint position information and Cooper simply did not have that and could not make the various segments of the trip in the general time frame you propose.

Several years ago on the DZ thread, if I remember this incorrectly would some of the former DZ posters correct me, Amazon indicated that the Lewis River between the Merwin Dam and the Columbia River had areas that were almost impassable for even small boats.  And trying to do this at night would greatly complicate the matter.  From the Merwin Dam area, it is probably about 30 miles to the Columbia River and then about another 20 miles upstream to the Tina Bar area.  At best, it would probably take at least five hours for that segment of trip.

In the Portland Airport area, I presume that the road adjacent to the Columbia River is the one you are referring to.  I drove over that very road a few weeks back and I spent several hours shopping at a mall that is located between that road and the Portland Airport.  It would be quite a hike for Cooper to walk from the Columbia River to the Portland Airport terminal.  He would have to take a lengthy walk down the I-205 area east of the airport and then approach the terminal area from the southeast.  That would be a lengthy walk and someone would probably have remembered seeing him and mentioned it to the FBI.  Very few people arrive at airport terminals after walking five miles or so.  And he certainly could not have climbed the airport fence in broad daylight without the tower and security people seeing him.

So to make a long story short, may I suggest that your ideas need further work.  Good luck.

Robert99 
 

georger

  • Guest
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1118 on: October 25, 2016, 12:34:29 AM »
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Is there ANY way that the Ingrams could have planted the currency (or been shown where it lay) and led Brian to the spot AND ALSO have the currency shard field documented in the TV news segment that Georger posted?

I don't see it, but Maybe Bruce can do some remote viewing, channeling or just plain imagining out of the box.  ;)

377

... they might have been tipped to money being out there so went looking. 
 

georger

  • Guest
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1119 on: October 25, 2016, 12:54:12 AM »
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
If, and I mean if the money got there via dredge it should of placed the money all over the place due to slurry coming out of the pipe (liquid) possibly portions going right back into the river, I don't know. if they found pieces at 3 feet, isn't that already below, or with the dredge layer?

The bag, if it was intact could of been discarded as trash if it ever surfaced....

Not necessarily. Even the whole bag of money would have been shredded then compacted into a relatively small space very quickly, against the infinitely greater volume of sand and other debris being processed and forced into the tube. This isn't like a stirring pot. The money would have been deposited in a very small area then covered quickly. Spreading might have moved the portion that did not drain back into the Columbia. As people have noted erosion is quick and decisive at Tina Bar so  there is a possibility the original deposit(s) might have been moved further north, away from the debris pile, say in the first year or two after 1974. Remember there were several very high water periods with lots of erosion at Tina Bar after the dredging and into 1976. 1976, for example, saw even higher flood levels numbers at Tina Bar than 1980 which Palmer cited! I dont think Palmer looked into the water levels at Tina Bar very closely - I think he was merely citing a hydrologist whose concern (because of Himmelsbach) was the Washougal vs. Tina Bar.

But as far as I can tell the mechanics of the dredging is compatable or matches pretty closely the forensic scene people found during the excavation of the Ingram find... including a confined area where bundles and related money shards buried as deep as 3 feet are all found in the same general area leading :"down stream" of the dredging pile locations (not that far away).   
     
 

georger

  • Guest
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1120 on: October 25, 2016, 01:33:38 AM »
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Is there ANY way that the Ingrams could have planted the currency (or been shown where it lay) and led Brian to the spot AND ALSO have the currency shard field documented in the TV news segment that Georger posted?

I don't see it, but Maybe Bruce can do some remote viewing, channeling or just plain imagining out of the box.  ;)

377

I'm trying to think what reason Dwayne Ingram would have had for concocting a story about how he found the money.

It seems he realized (pretty early on) that it was likely the Cooper money.  Did he think he couldn't just return it to a bank (it would be identified), so he figured he'd have more public sympathy to a claim if it was an 8 year old that found it?

If that's the case, it seems to me he was right.  I'm not a lawyer, but from my couple of law classes the insurance company would seem to be the rightful owner of all of the money -- or at least its cash equivalent.

It seems he realized (pretty early on) that it was likely the Cooper money?

He didn't. This has all been explained before, in detail (using FBI summaries). Read the thread. 
 

Offline Shutter

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 9300
  • Thanked: 1025 times
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1121 on: October 25, 2016, 07:46:34 AM »
The dredge is still hard to dismiss just as the plane is also hard to dismiss. these are two mechanical devices that are facts, and human intervention being speculation!

we have an early report from the FBI stating it's possible a satchel could of made it through.
I have emailed several dredge/pump companies stating the same.
The dredge operation was offshore of the crime scene.
The material was deposited near the crime scene.
The plane crossed somewhere upstream.

I was hoping to get a test with a dredge done several months ago, but the testing never occurred due to availability. now, did it happen this way? I have no idea since no testing was done, but it needs to be in order to figure out what happened. I also wish someone would take a few bills, wrap them in a rubber band, and place it in an area similar, or close to the actual place the money was found to try and recreate what happened to the money.

nobody seems to know what the money would look like after being submerged for several years (in a bag) prior to being found on the shoreline. Cooper "clogging up the dredge" is only one scenario, and not the possibility of only losing the money. I believe we have far too many possibilities to dismiss prior to turning Cooper into 007 with motor boats, and cinematic type escapes.
 

Offline Bill Rollins

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 39
  • Thanked: 1 times
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1122 on: October 25, 2016, 08:40:50 AM »
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login

Bill,

First, let me say welcome to the thread and you certainly seem to be more stable emotionally than Bruce Smith was indicating recently.

Basically, in your statements above you are assuming that Cooper knew his location when he jumped.  Actually, the airliner was above a 5000 foot overcast and several lower cloud layers and it is very, very unlikely that he could estimate his positon to within a radius of 20 miles.  Your statements require pinpoint position information and Cooper simply did not have that and could not make the various segments of the trip in the general time frame you propose.

Several years ago on the DZ thread, if I remember this incorrectly would some of the former DZ posters correct me, Amazon indicated that the Lewis River between the Merwin Dam and the Columbia River had areas that were almost impassable for even small boats.  And trying to do this at night would greatly complicate the matter.  From the Merwin Dam area, it is probably about 30 miles to the Columbia River and then about another 20 miles upstream to the Tina Bar area.  At best, it would probably take at least five hours for that segment of trip.

In the Portland Airport area, I presume that the road adjacent to the Columbia River is the one you are referring to.  I drove over that very road a few weeks back and I spent several hours shopping at a mall that is located between that road and the Portland Airport.  It would be quite a hike for Cooper to walk from the Columbia River to the Portland Airport terminal.  He would have to take a lengthy walk down the I-205 area east of the airport and then approach the terminal area from the southeast.  That would be a lengthy walk and someone would probably have remembered seeing him and mentioned it to the FBI.  Very few people arrive at airport terminals after walking five miles or so.  And he certainly could not have climbed the airport fence in broad daylight without the tower and security people seeing him.

So to make a long story short, may I suggest that your ideas need further work.  Good luck.

Robert99

Robert,

First, regarding Cooper's jump, think about this from the perspective of an engineer and instrument-rated pilot (which I am and I believe Cooper is as well).  Why wouldn't you jump on a clear moonlit night?  Seems much easier, doesn't it?

Surely jumping on a clear night simplifies Cooper's task, but what about the chase planes?  Cooper knows there will be chase planes, so he can't jump on a clear night because they will see him and report his position as he descends on his parachute.  Before he knows it, he will be surrounded by police, FBI, helicopters, etc.  The clear night jump leads to an easy capture and Cooper knows this.  Thus he selects a night with basically zero visibility above 5000', but clear below with 10-15 miles of visibility.

So since aircraft use avionics to determine their position when flying, Cooper configures some avionics device to determine his position.  I believe it is DME (distance measuring equipment).  DME was the latest and the greatest in 1971, but it could have been a standard NAV or ADF (automatic direction finder).  Either way, Cooper knew exactly where he was from the avionics in his briefcase (battery(s) and mass of wires).  I believe Cooper took a half a dozen trips from PDX to SEA in the month prior to the hijacking, testing this equipment.  He had it calibrated to work, you can be assured.  And next look at where he was projected to have landed.  From the FBI Landing Zone Map at Sluggo's website, it is estimated that he jumped at point A and if he pulled his ripcord soon after the jump, he landed at point B.  So Cooper's plan was to drift towards the well-lit Merwin Dam, land in the fields south and west of the dam, and then walk a short distance to the Lewis River.  This isn't an accident!!  If Cooper landed 20 miles north in Pigeon Springs, which looks like an area with logging roads and timber harvests, I would agree that he jumped blindly.  But seeing the precision with which he jumped and drifted, I realize this was his plan (Cooper is a pilot, so he has the same winds aloft data as Northwest, so he calculated his drift distance and jump point earlier in the day).

I believe that the Lewis River is navigable from the dam to the river, if you take the correct route.  At one point the river splits, and one branch has waterfalls, I believe.  One map I saw showed mile 21 at the dam, so it is about 21 miles to the Columbia.  From there it is only about 8 miles to Tena Bar.  But you are correct, this trip will require a few hours in a small craft like a 12' aluminum boat.  The advantage, though, is that he avoids any roadblocks and is miles away from the dropzone in a quiet rural area when he arrives at Tena Bar.  Be assured again that Cooper has made this trip numerous times in the month prior to the hijacking.

I don't know what PDX was like in 1971, but there may not have been a perimeter fence.  Also, where Cooper is a pilot, he may have known of a more direct route to the terminal.  The economy parking lot today is about 1-1/2 miles east of the terminal, but they provide a free shuttle service to the terminal.  Did that parking lot and service exist in 1971?  I'm not sure of this next tidbit, as there are limited aerial views of the airport in 1971, but the I-205 bridge appeared to be under construction at the time.  If you check Google Earth, you will see several marinas along the Columbia in the vicinity of the airport.  One is almost directly across from the terminal. 

According to Google, it is at best a 2.8 mile walk to the terminal from the I-205 bridge, and takes about 1 hour.  And even if people saw him, it wouldn't necessarily lead investigators to a boat!

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login

Again, Cooper has surveyed PDX and made the trip from Tena Bar to PDX numerous times in the month prior to the hijacking.  He has a plan!
 

Offline Bill Rollins

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 39
  • Thanked: 1 times
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1123 on: October 25, 2016, 09:15:59 AM »
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
The dredge is still hard to dismiss just as the plane is also hard to dismiss. these are two mechanical devices that are facts, and human intervention being speculation!

we have an early report from the FBI stating it's possible a satchel could of made it through.
I have emailed several dredge/pump companies stating the same.
The dredge operation was offshore of the crime scene.
The material was deposited near the crime scene.
The plane crossed somewhere upstream.

I was hoping to get a test with a dredge done several months ago, but the testing never occurred due to availability. now, did it happen this way? I have no idea since no testing was done, but it needs to be in order to figure out what happened. I also wish someone would take a few bills, wrap them in a rubber band, and place it in an area similar, or close to the actual place the money was found to try and recreate what happened to the money.

nobody seems to know what the money would look like after being submerged for several years (in a bag) prior to being found on the shoreline. Cooper "clogging up the dredge" is only one scenario, and not the possibility of only losing the money. I believe we have far too many possibilities to dismiss prior to turning Cooper into 007 with motor boats, and cinematic type escapes.

The Citizen Sleuths have done extensive testing on the money and rubber bands.  They have concluded that the money did not arrive at Tena Bar from natural causes.  And Andrade also agrees, as the money is found within about a 1 square foot area and the bills are neatly stacked one on top of the other.  This order would not be seen if the money floated down the river or went through a dredge machine.  It's human intervention, either a plant of the money at some date, or as I state, it arrived there with Cooper on the night of the hijacking and was lost by mistake.

You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login

You may call it a cinematic escape that would be typical of a James Bond film, however, it you look at Cooper's plan, everything is done as a rational decision to avoid a problem.  For instance, by using a boat to get to PDX, Cooper avoids leaving any traceable evidence for investigators. 

So tell me a better scenario where we no longer have questions like:

1) how did Cooper get to PDX without leaving evidence?
2) How come we have no trace of him at the drop zone, no dead body, no parachute, no money?
3) How did he do this without an accomplice?
4) How did the money get to Tena Bar and why was it in such an "orderly" condition?
5) Why no missing persons report?

I have a high degree of confidence that this is how Cooper planned his escapade, and it is so ingenious, that it has bewildered everyone for 45 years.
 

Offline MarkBennett

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 467
  • Thanked: 26 times
Re: Flight Path And Related Issues
« Reply #1124 on: October 25, 2016, 10:02:38 AM »
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login
Is there ANY way that the Ingrams could have planted the currency (or been shown where it lay) and led Brian to the spot AND ALSO have the currency shard field documented in the TV news segment that Georger posted?

I don't see it, but Maybe Bruce can do some remote viewing, channeling or just plain imagining out of the box.  ;)

377

I'm trying to think what reason Dwayne Ingram would have had for concocting a story about how he found the money.

It seems he realized (pretty early on) that it was likely the Cooper money.  Did he think he couldn't just return it to a bank (it would be identified), so he figured he'd have more public sympathy to a claim if it was an 8 year old that found it?

If that's the case, it seems to me he was right.  I'm not a lawyer, but from my couple of law classes the insurance company would seem to be the rightful owner of all of the money -- or at least its cash equivalent.

It seems he realized (pretty early on) that it was likely the Cooper money?

He didn't. This has all been explained before, in detail (using FBI summaries). Read the thread.
I guess it depends on what is meant by "pretty early on".  The money was found on Sunday, February 10.  The FBI was notified, assembled a team and began digging on Tuesday, February 12.  Regardless of what the thread says, it's impossible for the Ingrams not to have realized it was Cooper money within hours -- not days.